Liam, I am not sure I have said or implied as much as you are finding. What I know I have said is that rockred skis epscially in the tail promote poor technique and don't give the proper feedback when the skier is not using correct movements. The other thing I said is that there is a balance between finding skis that give proper feedback and ones that are forgiving enough and that everyone needs to find that balance themselves.
For those on the site that continue to want to progress with PMTS I pass along what I have learned while working diligently at perfecting those movements. Those that have no interest in PMTS movements or only a passing interest can pretty much disregard my comments (which I assume that they do).
I guess we could get into a long discussion about what defines good skiing but that really would be a waste of everyone's time. In the end I can only talk about skis and equipment that supports or does not support that type of movements that I am trying to produce in my skiing. Of course there are many that have no interest in producing those movements and therefore don't need to listen to my comments on skis and equipment. I'm fine with that and it is as it should be.